send this to... Digg it! | Technorati | Del.icio.us | Reddit | Furl | Spurl |
A week of IPCC news - February 4, 2007
Courtesy of H.E.Taylor, here is this week's GW news roundup, installment 1 (IPCC related stories only)
(skip to bottom)
(skip to bottom)
The IPCC released its 2007 Summary for Policymakers on Friday:
- 2007/02/02: IPCC: (pdf 2.3 megs) 2007 Summary for Policymakers
- 2007/02/02: UCAR:IPCC: (pdf 2.3 megs) 2007 Summary for Policymakers
- 2007/02/02: IPCC: IPCC adopts major assessment of climate change science
- 2007/02/02: RealClimate: The IPCC Fourth Assessment SPM
- 2007/02/02: NSU: Climate report released - Fourth round of IPCC pins down blame for global warming
Lots of people reported:
- Click here to read more
- 2007/02/02: PhysicsWeb: Mankind to blame for global warming says IPCC - UN panel backs science of climate change with "very high confidence"
- 2007/02/02: PhysOrg: Report: Human activity fuels global warming
- 2007/02/03: Yahoo: Global warming to continue for centuries
- 2007/02/02: CSW: Interview with BBC: Keeping the Administration honest on the IPCC report conclusions
- 2007/02/02: DeSmogBlog: Global warming of last 50 years "unusual" in at least the previous 1300 years
- 2007/02/03: GWW: 2007 IPCC report released to the world
- 2007/02/03: TheAge: 2500 scientists, 1200 pages, and one quibble
- 2007/02/02: IHT: A look at the climate change report's main findings
- 2007/02/02: Economist: Heating up - A gloomy UN-backed report is published
- 2007/02/02: Yahoo: How language on climate change has evolved [2007, 2001, 1995 & 1990 text comparison]
- 2007/02/02: BDL: IPCC Global Warming Projections
- 2007/02/01: SwissInfo: UN panel issues tough climate change verdict
- 2007/02/03: Xinhuanet: Grim warning on climate change
- 2007/02/02: GristMill: IPCC Summary for Policymakers released
- 2007/02/02: Deltoid: IPCC AR4 released
- 2007/02/02: PlanetArk: U.N. Panel Blames Humans for Warming
And what did the various nations have to say?:
- 2007/02/03: AFP: Bush changes global warming talk, but not action
- 2007/02/02: PhysOrg: Climate Report Won't Signal [US] Policy Change
- 2007/02/03: ABC(Au): Aust 'must adapt' to global warming
The Federal Government says Australia should be focused on adapting to climate change, after a United Nations (UN) report on global warming predicted rising sea levels and more severe droughts and heatwaves - 2007/02/03: DeSmogBlog: IPCC quotes from around the world
- 2007/02/03: ClimateArk: Beijing shifts the blame
China is well aware of the dangers of global warming, but feels developed countries should bear the brunt of the cost of the bill for now - 2007/02/03: SF Gate: Report spurs calls for aggressive action - White House accepts findings but rejects mandatory cuts
- 2007/02/03: BBC: Climate paper prompts call to act
Governments around the world have called for urgent action to tackle climate change, after a major report said mankind was very likely the cause. The EU said it was the starkest warning yet, while the UK said climate change threatened world peace and prosperity. The US administration said the report was "valuable", but rejected mandatory controls to reduce greenhouse gases. - 2007/02/02: Yahoo: White House rejects mandatory CO2 caps
- 2007/02/01: PhysOrg: No Sign Bush to Vary Greenhouse Gas Tack
- 2007/01/30: GristMill: Space mirrors!
Some think that things are worse than the SPM says:
- 2007/02/04: DenverPost: Excluded data push warning to red
- 2007/02/01: NSU: Sea levels 'rising faster than predicted' - Climate-change figures since 1990 offer test of IPCC projections
- 2007/02/03: TPM: You may not have noticed but...[sea level projections]
- 2007/02/02: GristMill: Hidden bombshell in the IPCC Fourth Assessment
- 2007/02/02: PlanetArk: Seas Rising Faster than U.N. Predicts - Study
- 2007/02/02: CliProg: Hidden Bombshell in the IPCC Fourth Assessment
- 2007/02/02: ABC(Au): Climate report fails to highlight extent of global warming, Flannery says
- 2007/02/02: ABC(Au): Sea level rises underestimated: scientist
- 2007/01/28: WaPo: New Climate Report Too Rosy, Experts Say [ignores Greenland and Antarctic melts]
- 2007/01/31: CliProg: Neglected Ice Sheets Water Down IPCC Report
- 2007/01/29: Yahoo: New climate report too rosy, experts say
- 2007/01/29: CDreams: AP: New Climate Report Too Rosy, Experts Say
- 2007/01/27: IHT: Melting ice means global warming report all wet, say some experts who warn it'll be even worse
Some in the blogosphere had unique reactions:
- 2007/02/02: Deltoid: IPCC AR4 leaks wrong
- 2007/02/02: ERabett: An early valentine for the Stoat
- 2007/02/02: Stoat: SPM proves less exciting than expected
James Annan deserves a reward for coining the word 'bloggorhea':
- 2007/02/04: JEB: Some IPCC SPM comments
I'm not going to give a broad overview, as there is already a plethora of rather boring bloggorhea...
Then there was the usual commentary:
- 2007/02/03: TDC: Scientists: Global Warming Report Predicts Warm, Dry Colorado
- 2007/02/05: KoreaHerald: Saving ourselves
- 2007/02/04: ClimateArk: A Disaster Epic (in Slo-Mo)
- 2007/02/04: ClimateArk: Accelerated warming now requires an accelerated response
- 2007/02/04: Scotsman: Another warning... and another chance for the world to do nothing
- 2007/02/03: WT&GN: Humans driving climate change: Report; Prompt action crucial
- 2007/02/02: ABC(Au): Global warming effects will last centuries, UN warns
- 2007/02/03: ABC(Au): UN global warming report prompts call to act
- 2007/02/04: SundayTelegraph(Au): A planet on the edge
- 2007/02/03: Yomiuri: Warming to alter Japan / Govt climate report warns of agricultural shift northward
- 2007/02/03: CBS: U.S., Australia Pushed To Ink Kyoto Pact - Officials, Environmentalists Seek Reduction In Greenhouse Gas Emissions After Global Warming Report
- 2007/02/03: TStar: Canadians will be hit harder
- 2007/02/03: SF Gate: Climate Change Report - Grim global warming prognosis for Western U.S. - International group says quick action can mitigate some effects
- 2007/02/03: TheAge: So now we know, and the ball's in our court
- 2007/02/02: ENS: Global Warming Shock Wave Awakens World Leaders
- 2007/02/02: Telegraph(UK): This was the IPCC saying 'We told you so'
- 2007/02/02: Independent(UK): Ten years left to avert catastrophe
- 2007/02/03: Independent(UK): Global warming: the final warning
According to yesterday's UN report, the world will be a much hotter place by 2100. This will be the impact ... - 2007/02/03: EnvEcon: The worst kept secret [the IPCC story]
- 2007/02/02: SwissInfo: Mankind to blame for climate change
- 2007/02/02: SwissInfo: Swiss urge action over "alarming" climate study
- 2007/02/02: Xinhuanet: UN panel issues toughest warning on global warming
- 2007/02/02: CBC: Climate report predicts major consequences for Canada
- 2007/02/03: SMH: Race against the clock
- 2007/02/02: Time: Climate Change: Case Closed?
- 2007/02/02: AP: Global Warming to Continue for Centuries
- 2007/02/03: Guardian(UK): Worse than we thought - Report warns of 4C rise by 2100 - Floods and food and water shortages likely
- 2007/02/03: Guardian(UK): Climate change - No more excuses
- 2007/02/03: Guardian(UK): Why the news about warming is worse than we thought: feedback
- 2007/02/03: Guardian(UK): The scientists spoke cautiously but the graphs said it all
- 2007/02/02: Guardian(UK): Humans blamed for climate change
- 2007/02/02: Guardian(UK): Fossil fuel and land use behind CO2 rise
- 2007/02/02: Guardian(UK): Q&A: The IPCC report on global warming
- 2007/02/02: Guardian(UK): An unforgivable truth
Today's report on climate change underlines how utterly pathetic has been Britain's effort to curb emissions - 2007/02/02: GristMill: IPCC: Now that we've all agreed, let's disagree
- 2007/02/02: GristMill: IPCC got you down? Here are 11 things you can do
- 2007/02/01: GristMill: Last-minute IPCC haggling
- 2007/02/01: TerraDaily: Scientists Hammer Out Key Climate Report Due Friday
- 2007/02/02: TreeHugger: The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Report
- 2007/02/02: WorldChanging: A Green Winter: A Citizen's Take on Global Warming
- 2007/02/02: PlanetArk: Global Warming: Impacts of Temperature Rises
- 2007/02/02: PlanetArk: U.N. Climate Panel and Past Reports
- 2007/02/02: PlanetArk: Draft Findings by U.N. Climate Panel
- 2007/02/02: PlanetArk: U.N. Panel to Link Warming to Humans...
- 2007/02/02: SciDaily: Evidence For Human-caused Global Warming Is Now 'Unequivocal'
- 2007/02/02: Eureka: New report presents strongest evidence yet of human link to global warming, Duke expert [Gabriele Hegerl] says
- 2007/02/02: EnergyBulletin: Global warming obstructionism - Word from participants who shall remain nameless is that China has taken the lead in global warming obstructionism in 2007.
- 2007/02/02: ZMag: Catastrophes Inevitable, Says New Report
- 2007/02/02: CBS: Global Warming To "Continue For Centuries" - Report From Top Scientists Urges Countries To Take Action, Calls Global Warming "Unequivocal"
- 2007/02/02: Xinhuanet: UN issues warning on global warming
- 2007/02/02: CBC: Paris report calls climate change 'unequivocal'
- 2007/02/02: AFP: Warming to worsen droughts, floods, storms this century: UN panel
- 2007/02/01: RealClimate: Quick pre-SPM round-up
- 2007/02/02: AP: Warming 'Likely' Man-Made, Unstoppable
- 2007/02/02: NYT: Panel Issues Bleak Report on Climate Change
- 2007/02/01: TechRev: Climate Change: "Many, Many Smoking Guns"
The fourth in a series of international reports, due out tomorrow, reflects better science and more-precise models. - 2007/02/01: PhysOrg: Climate Report Marks New Era in Global Warming Battle, Science Historian Says
"The scientific debate is over," said Spencer Weart, director of AIP's Center for History of Physics, in College Park, MD. "It now becomes an economic and political debate" over how to deal with the problem of global warming, he said. - 2007/02/02: BBC: The lights of Paris dimmed for five minutes on Thursday in a nationwide "lights out" campaign, aimed at raising public awareness over global warming.
- 2007/02/02: AP: Global Warming 'Very Likely' Man-Made
- 2007/02/01: CliProg: IPCC: Humans "VERY LIKELY" causing global warming
- 2007/02/01: TruthOut: Slow Going on Global Warming Report
- 2007/02/02: ABC(Au): UN panel blames humans for global warming
- 2007/02/01: PhysOrg: Last Day of Global Warming Talks in Paris
- 2007/02/01: PhysOrg: Humans 'Very Likely' Making Earth Warmer
- 2007/02/02: JQuiggin: IPCC out today
- 2007/02/01: PlanetArk: Climate Change Doom Reports don't Stack up [says IEA economist]
- 2007/02/01: PlanetArk: Sydney Heat Deaths to Soar Due to Climate Change
- 2007/02/01: BBC: Climatic changes seen around the world are "very likely" to have a human cause, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) will conclude
- 2007/02/01: CBC: Climate change report to say global warming 'very likely' man-made
- 2007/01/31: PhysOrg: Australia Temperatures to Soar in 65 Years
- 2007/01/31: PhysOrg: Slow Going on Global Warming Report
- 2007/01/31: DeSmogBlog: "Uncertainty:" Nine bullets in a 10-chamber gun
- 2007/01/31: TerraDaily: Global Warming Rise Of Over 4C If Atmospheric Carbon Doubles
- 2007/01/30: TerraDaily: Call For 'Climate Summit' As Scientists Ponder Grim Report
- 2007/01/31: ABC(US): Two of the Biggest Changes in Climate News -- The World Awaits Friday's Verdict in Paris
The world's scientists have produced these consensus reports every five years since 1991, but the biggest change since the last report in 2001 is clearly not in the science. It's in the audience. This time around, far more people are ready to listen. - 2007/01/31: PlanetArk: Clouds a Puzzle for UN Global Warming Panel
- 2007/01/31: PlanetArk: Millions to go Hungry, Waterless - Climate Report
- 2007/01/30: TruthOut: Millions to Go Hungry by 2080: Report
- 2007/01/30: TruthOut: Global Warming: The Vicious Circle
- 2007/01/30: TruthOut: Indonesia May Lose 2,000 Islands to Climate Change
- 2007/01/29: TruthOut: Some Experts Blast Latest Climate Report
- 2007/01/29: DeSmogBlog: Our Resource Page for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
- 2007/01/29: TerraDaily: Indonesia Could Lose Thousands Of Islands With Sea Level Rise
- 2007/01/29: TerraDaily: All Eyes On Scientists As Climate Summit Opens
- 2007/01/30: Yahoo: Climate change means hunger and thirst for billions: report
- 2007/01/30: BBC: Panel warns on Great Barrier Reef
Australia's famous Great Barrier Reef could be dead within decades because of the effects of global warming, according to a leaked report. - 2007/01/30: HindustanTimes: Millions to go hungry by 2080: report
- 2007/01/30: ABC(Au): UN report to condense and clarify climate change information
- 2007/01/30: CDreams: Reuters: Millions to Go Hungry, Waterless: Climate Report
- 2007/01/30: CDreams: Sun(UK): 10 Years to Save the Planet
- 2007/01/29: Reuters: Millions to go hungry, waterless: climate report
- 2007/01/29: MoJo:BlueMarble: Scary Impacts of Temperature Increases from Global Warming
- 2007/01/30: Sun(UK): 10 years to save the planet
- 2007/01/29: AP: World Scientists Meet on Global Warming
- 2007/01/30: ABC(Au): Scientists gather to report on global warming
- 2007/01/29: NewScientist: Major climate change report looks set to alarm
- 2007/01/29: PhysOrg: Global Warming May Affect Indonesia Isles
- 2007/01/29: PhysOrg: Study: Next decade 'crucial' on warming
- 2007/01/29: GristMill: The uncertain risk of catastrophic sea-level rise
- 2007/01/28: Stoat: AR4 and sea level
- 2007/01/28: TerraDaily: Climate Scientists Set To Serve Up A Slab Of Bad News
- 2007/01/29: IHT: World scientists meet to finalize global warming report
- 2007/01/29: TheAge: Scientist's 'Russian roulette' climate warning
The world is "playing Russian roulette" with its future by responding too slowly to climate change, a leading American scientist has warned ahead of the release of a major international report this week. But Professor Stephen Schneider told The Age that although Australian and US politics had been dominated for too long by "climate monkeys" who refused to take global warming seriously, he was more optimistic about the future because of the groundswell of community concern in both countries. - 2007/01/29: ClimateArk: Global Warming: The vicious circle
- 2007/01/29: PlanetArk: UN Climate Panel to Blame Humans for Warming
- 2007/01/29: PlanetArk: Global Warming: Impacts of Temperature Increases
- 2007/01/29: PlanetArk: Developing Powers Seen Critical to Climate Pact
- 2007/01/29: PlanetArk: Warming to Raise Seas for 1,000 Years - UN Draft
- 2007/01/30: PlanetArk: Indonesia May Lose 2,000 Islands to Climate Change
- 2007/01/30: PlanetArk: World Leaders Urged to Act on Global Warming Study
- 2007/01/29: Yahoo: Climate change hitting developing countries worst, says UN
- 2007/01/29: OilChange: IPCC: Climate Change Worse than Previously Thought
- 2007/01/29: CBC: World scientists meet on global warming
Scientists from around the world gathered Monday in Paris to finalize a long-awaited, authoritative report on climate change, expected to give a grim warning of rising temperatures and sea levels worldwide. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is to unveil its latest assessment of the environmental threat posed by global warming on Friday. - 2007/01/29: CBS: New Climate Report Too Rosy, Experts Say - Many top American scientists say global warming report expected this week understates dangers
- 2007/01/28: Times(UK): Last warning: 10 years to save world - Scientists say rising greenhouses gases will make climate change unstoppable in a decade
--regards--
PS. You can access the previous postings of this series here
--
"Socialism collapsed because it did not allow prices to tell the economic truth. Capitalism may collapse because it does not allow prices to tell the ecological truth."
- Oystein Dahle, former VP of Exxon Norway, May 31, 2005
Global Warming: http://www.autobahn.mb.ca/~het/enviro/globalwarming.html
GW News: http://www.autobahn.mb.ca/~het/enviro/gwnews.html
GW News Archive: http://www.autobahn.mb.ca/~het/enviro/gwna.html
H.E. Taylor http://www.autobahn.mb.ca/~het/
Labels: news
2 Comments:
At March 10, 2007 5:59 PM, Anonymous said…
I am a global warming skeptic. However I enjoy your site. Your articles are well thought out and reasoned.
All of your articles attempt to address the skeptics on a logical level and not by accusing critics of being on Exxon's payroll (I work for New York State.), Holocaust Deniers (My mother's sister survived Auschwitz.), flat earthers (Anyone who visits the seashore can see for himself why the Earth is round.), or a seven-day creationst (Sorry, I'm not one either.).
My problem with the AGW thesis is that is has not met six conditions that are critical for the theory.
To prove that Anthropogenic Global Warming exists the following conditions have to be met:
1.) the temperature of the earth is increasing;
2.) the temperature increase is beyond normal variation;
3.) the temperature increase will continue into the future;
4.) the temperature increase is related to Carbon Dioxide concentrations;
5.) Other plausible explanations have been rejected; and,
6.) The increase of Carbon Dioxide caused by human activity is the driving force.
I maintain that each of these conditions is an open issue.
I don't want to deal with each issue at preent, but I will give some ideas of the problems involved. Concerning my first point, why cannot NASA and CRU-UK agree on global temperatures? That they cannot indicates a problem of measurement. Also note that the drastic increase of surface temperatures as measured by weather stations is negatively correlated with the number of weather stations--there are many fewer weather stations now than there were 20 years ago. Additionally, there is still a difference between satellite and surface data. This has led two of the world's leading experts on this approach to measuring the earth's temperature--Christie and Spencer of the University of Alabama Huntsville to a very moderate position on temperature increase. Lastly, where tree ring data is available(unfortunately not enough sites) it does not confirm the readings of the surface stations.
So lets keep this civil and scientific. I await answers to my questions. I also hope to have a civil discourse
At March 11, 2007 2:01 PM, coby said…
Hi Anonymous,
IMO, all 6 points you present are very well established (I agree they are the necessary building blocks of the AGW case), but you did not wish to discuss them...anyway, read the IPCC TAR WG1 report (in the side bar) they very thouroughly address all those points. (thanks for your complimentary words, btw!)
I'm not sure why you would find something surprising or worisome about two different analyses of global temperature arriving at slightly different results. That is the nature of science, no two measurements are ever exactly the same.
Regarding satellite readings, see here
I do not know that you are correct that tree ring proxies disagree with weather station readings, but regardless there are many many other indicators that show warming.
Thanks for the comment, I look forward to your response.
Post a Comment
<< Home